Handle Marketplace leads by replying in minutes, answering the exact question asked, asking one question that moves toward a visit, and getting the buyer's phone number to continue by text. Add the buyer to your CRM with the car attached so nothing lives only in Messenger. The first reply to is this still available should confirm the car and offer a specific day and time.
Why Marketplace messages are different
A Marketplace message is not a form fill. There is no phone number, no email and no consent record. The buyer typed a few words in Messenger, often while looking at several cars. If you reply late or with a generic line, they have already messaged three other sellers.
The goals are the same as any lead: respond fast, get a way to reach them, set an appointment. See how fast to respond to internet leads.
The response playbook
- Assign an owner. One person per rep's listings watches Messenger, at set times. Unowned inboxes die.
- Reply in minutes during store hours. Set a rule, such as every new message gets a reply before the next one is read.
- Answer first, ask second. Do not answer a question with a question and nothing else.
- Get a mobile number. Ask for it as a convenience, not a demand: it is easier to send photos by text.
- Add the lead to the CRM with the vehicle attached, tagged Marketplace.
- Offer a day and time. Never end on come by anytime.
- Follow up. If they go quiet, a second message the next day with something new, such as another photo or a similar car. Stop when they say stop.
Five sample replies
Samples with a fictional store, Premier Auto, and rep, Dave. Short, one question, no prices or payments, and aimed at a specific time. Adjust the car and the days.
Hi, this is Dave at Premier Auto. Yes, the Equinox is still here. Would you like to see it today or tomorrow?
Confirm the car, then a day. Check the lot first so you never say yes to a sold car.
Good question. I would rather sit down with a manager and give you real numbers than guess in a message. Could you come by Thursday at 5, or is Saturday morning better?
Do not quote a number in Messenger. Move to a conversation.
We do. If you tell me the year, make and mileage, I can have our used car manager look at it when you come in. What day works for a quick look?
Do not give a trade value by message.
Thanks for coming that far. I can have the car clean and ready for you. What time would you want to arrive, and what is the best number to reach you in case traffic changes things?
Do not promise a hold you cannot keep. Ask your manager's policy first.
Absolutely. I will walk the car and send a video within the hour. What number should I text it to?
Turns a request into a phone number and a reason to reply. See the walkaround video shot list.
Mistakes to avoid
- Replying with a copy-and-paste line that ignores the buyer's question.
- Saying a car is available without checking.
- Quoting a price or payment in Messenger and being held to it.
- Texting a number a buyer gave you in Messenger without checking your consent process. Get a clear yes to text first, and honor stop requests.
- Letting the lead sit in Messenger only. Messages in someone's personal inbox disappear when that rep leaves.
Tools
The hard part is not the reply, it is the capture and the follow-up. DealFlo's Marketplace tools add a buyer as a lead with the car attached in one tap, and then the lead is worked like any other. See Marketplace lead follow-up. Listings on third-party sites such as AutoTrader have the same issue: leads that arrive and never get a reply. See AutoTrader lead follow-up.
What to measure
- Reply time from the first message to your first answer.
- Number rate: conversations where you got a phone number.
- Appointments set from Marketplace conversations.
- Shows and sold from those appointments, tagged by source in the CRM.
If you cannot count these, tag Marketplace as a lead source in the CRM today. A source you do not measure is a source you cannot improve.
Frequently asked questions
How fast should I reply to a Marketplace message?
As fast as you can during store hours, ideally within minutes. There is no official benchmark for Marketplace specifically, but buyers message several sellers at once, so the first useful reply tends to win the conversation.
Should I ask for the buyer's phone number in the first message?
Answer the question first, then ask for a number as a convenience for sending photos or a video. Asking before answering feels like a form.
What do I do when a Marketplace buyer goes silent?
Send one follow-up the next day with something new, such as a video or a similar car. If there is still no answer, log it and move on without repeated pings.
See it run on your own leads
A 30-minute walkthrough on your store's real lead sources: the first text, the graded call, and the follow-up that never quits.