Can dealerships pay for or incentivize Google reviews?

No. Google prohibits reviews posted because of an incentive, and an FTC rule bars buying reviews tied to a particular sentiment. You can ask. You cannot pay or reward.

The short answer

No. Google's review policy prohibits content posted due to an incentive offered by a business, and the FTC's consumer reviews rule (16 CFR Part 465) makes it unfair or deceptive to give compensation or incentives in exchange for reviews that express a particular sentiment. A dealership may ask every customer for an honest review, but may not pay, reward, gate or script the answers.

What Google's policy says

Google's Maps contributed content policy lists Incentivized or Biased Reviews as rating manipulation, which is not allowed and will be removed from Maps. It prohibits content posted due to an incentive offered by a business. It also says merchants may not offer incentives for reviews, revisions or removal of negative reviews, discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers (Google's policy).

The same policy says merchants may solicit or encourage content that represents a genuine experience, but should not require or pressure users to leave reviews while on the premises, ask staff to meet a review quota, or ask that specific content be included. It treats current or former employment as a possible conflict of interest.

What the FTC rule says

The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials is 16 CFR Part 465. Section 465.2 covers fake or false reviews, 465.4 covers buying positive or negative reviews, 465.5 covers insider reviews and testimonials, 465.6 covers company-controlled review websites, and 465.7 covers review suppression (16 CFR Part 465, Cornell LII).

Under section 465.4, it is an unfair or deceptive practice to offer payment or other incentives for reviews that express a particular sentiment, whether favorable or unfavorable, when the incentive is given in exchange for or conditioned on that sentiment, directly or by implication (16 CFR 465.4).

Section 465.7 prohibits using unfounded legal threats, intimidation or public false accusations to stop or remove a review, and bars misrepresenting that the reviews you display are all or most of the reviews you received when you have hidden some based on rating or negative sentiment. It does not prohibit removing content on criteria applied equally to every review, such as harassing or clearly false content (16 CFR 465.7).

What is allowed and what is not

Review practices for a dealership
PracticeAllowed?Why
Ask every customer for an honest reviewYesGoogle allows soliciting genuine experience content
Text a direct review link after deliveryYesSame request to everyone, with texting consent
Reply publicly to every reviewYesReplies are not incentives
Gift card, discount or free service for a reviewNoGoogle bans incentive-driven reviews. FTC 465.4 applies when tied to sentiment
Entry into a drawing for leaving a reviewNoIt is still an incentive from the business under Google's policy
Discount if the customer removes or edits a negative reviewNoGoogle bans incentives for revising or removing reviews
Ask only customers you think are happyNoGoogle bans selectively soliciting positive reviews
Send unhappy customers to a private feedback form instead of GoogleNoThat is the same selective solicitation
Staff review quotas or per-review commissionsNoGoogle names staff review quotas as prohibited
Tell customers what to writeNoGoogle bans requesting specific content
Employees or relatives post reviewsNoGoogle treats employment as a conflict of interest. FTC 465.5 covers insider reviews
Hire an agency that buys or generates reviewsNoBuying reviews and fake reviews are covered by 465.2 and 465.4
Threaten legal action to remove a review you know is trueNoFTC 465.7 covers unfounded legal threats
Flag a review that is fake or violates policyYesReporting a policy violation to Google is the legitimate route

What to do instead

  1. Make the ask part of delivery and send it to every buyer. See how to get Google reviews at delivery.
  2. Reply to every review, including bad ones, with a name and a number to call.
  3. Fix what negative reviews point to. It is the only durable way to change your rating.
  4. Report fake or policy-violating reviews through Google, not by threatening the reviewer.
  5. Write the rules down for staff and check your vendors follow them.

DealFlo's review requests go out after delivery to buyers, without incentives.

Frequently asked questions

Can I give a gift to every customer, not tied to a review?

A genuine thank-you gift that is not conditioned on a review is not an incentive for a review, but keep it separate from the review request. If the gift and the review ask arrive together, it can look like an exchange. Ask counsel.

Can a dealership respond to a negative review with an offer to make it right?

Yes, publicly offer to talk and fix the problem. Do not tie it to the customer changing or deleting the review. Google's policy prohibits offering incentives for revisions or removal.

What happens if Google finds incentivized reviews?

Google says it removes them from Maps. Repeated violations can bring further restrictions on the Business Profile, according to its fake engagement policy.

Josh Skwarek
Josh SkwarekFounder & CEO, DealFlo

Josh Skwarek spent eight years in car dealerships as a salesperson, finance manager and sales manager, including a stretch as a top five Nissan salesperson in the United States. DealFlo grew out of the lead process Josh had been managing by hand.

See it run on your own leads

A 30-minute walkthrough on your store's real lead sources: the first text, the graded call, and the follow-up that never quits.